The organizers have put together a balanced and brilliant panel, something which is always the case with Federalist Society events, making this a must attend for those who want to hear reasoned debate from both sides of the arguments over counterterrorism.
The panelists include:
Mr. Steven A. Engel, Partner, Dechert LLP
The Hon. Neal K. Katyal, Principal Deputy Solicitor General, U.S. Department of Justice
Mr. David B. Rivkin, Jr., Partner, Baker & Hostetler LLP and Co-Chairman, Center for Law and Counterterrorism
Prof. Stephen I. Vladeck, American University Washington College of Law
Prof. Neomi Rao, George Mason University School of Law, Moderator
Exactly one year has passed since President Obama declared he would close Guantanamo.
And today, The Washington Post reports that his Department of Justice Task Force will recommend “that nearly 50 of the 196 detainees at the U.S. military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, should be held indefinitely without trial under the laws of war.” How long will we have to wait before human rights groups begin to call President Obama a war criminal? How long until those who called for President Bush’s indictment by an international tribunal make the same call?
Don’t hold your breath. Back in 2005 Amnesty International called Guantanamo “the Gulag of our times” equating the Bush administration to war criminals. Now, their tune has moderated –of course in their eyes it is still bad that Guantanamo remains open– but they’ve toned down their Gulag language and now we hear “people around the world who care about human rights and the rule of law will be extremely disheartened” by President Obama’s failure to close Guantanamo. Disheartened is probably an improvement from the dyspepsia which gripped most of these people during the Bush administration.
Not to be outdone in moderation, Anthony Romero of the ACLU blandly stated Read the full entry »
This video shows the “rehabilitation” program in Saudi Arabia which former GITMO detainees were sent to. One program graduate, Said Ali al-Shihiri is second in command of al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula and was a key planner of the christmas bombing plot. Note how the prison is a palace and the rehabilitation center is akin to a luxury resort. Between this and Uighurs in Bermuda, it’s no wonder that al Qaeda recruiting is up.
Bobby Chesney at the University of Texas prepared a handy list of National Security Law related events at the AALS conference in New Orleans January 6-10, 2010. I’ve included the list below.
Gregory S. McNeal is a professor at the Pennsyvlania State University. His research focuses on counterterrorism, with a particular substantive focus on criminal law and procedure, national security law and international law.
Full Biography
“The expertise of the authors and the contributors (all specialists in the rarified world of international criminal tribunals and the broader fields of international human rights) ensured that the essays are uniformly well written, focused on important topics, and interesting.” –The Law and Politics Book Review